Movements

Which is best, quartz or automatic watch?

Neither quartz nor automatic is better for everyone. Compare accuracy, upkeep, durability and cost to see which movement suits how you wear a watch.

On this page
  1. Accuracy
  2. Upkeep: batteries vs servicing
  3. Daily use and setting the time
  4. Durability and handling
  5. Longevity
  6. Why automatic watches often cost more
  7. Which one suits you
  8. Frequently asked questions

Neither is better for everyone. A quartz watch is more accurate and needs less day-to-day attention, but it needs a battery every few years. An automatic watch has no battery and is valued for its mechanical design, but it has to be worn or wound to keep running, and it needs servicing. The better choice depends on how you want to wear and look after a watch.

Accuracy

A quartz movement is regulated by a quartz crystal that vibrates 32,768 times per second. A typical quartz watch keeps time to within about 15 seconds per month.

An automatic is a mechanical movement regulated by a balance wheel and hairspring. Its accuracy depends on the movement, its regulation and its service. A typical automatic can vary by a few seconds per day, and a poorly regulated one can vary by much more. A watch certified as a chronometer must meet the COSC standard of -4 to +6 seconds per day during testing. Watch movements explained sets the two types side by side.

Upkeep: batteries vs servicing

Quartz upkeep is simple. The battery needs replacing every few years, depending on the cell and the watch. Many solar-powered quartz watches avoid this altogether, and some use batteries that last much longer. A battery change is usually quick and inexpensive.

Automatic upkeep is less frequent but more involved. The lubricants in the movement age and need renewing, so the watch needs a service every few years. Intervals vary by brand and movement, so check the manufacturer’s advice. Service costs more than a battery change, and the price depends on the brand and the complexity of the movement.

Daily use and setting the time

This is where the two feel most different. A quartz watch keeps time whether or not you wear it. You can leave it in a drawer for weeks and pick it up with the right time showing.

An automatic keeps running only while it is worn or wound. If it is left unworn for longer than its power reserve, it stops, and you have to wind it and set the time again. How automatic watches work explains why. Some people enjoy this routine. Others find it a nuisance. Neither view is wrong.

Durability and handling

A quartz movement has fewer moving parts, which makes it less sensitive to some knocks and to wear. An automatic is robust when it is in good condition and well sealed, but its many small parts need careful handling. Keep either type away from strong magnets, and check the water resistance rating before wearing it in or near water.

Longevity

Both types can last for decades. An automatic lasts when it is serviced regularly. A quartz watch lasts as long as the battery is changed and the movement remains repairable. A quartz movement that has been discontinued may be harder to repair if its electronic parts are no longer available. A mechanical movement can often be repaired with new or refurbished parts.

Why automatic watches often cost more

Automatics generally cost more to make. A mechanical movement has many more parts than a quartz movement, and many of them are finished and assembled by hand. Quartz movements are simpler and made in large volumes, which keeps their cost down. Price also reflects the brand, case material and finishing, so two automatics can differ a lot in cost.

Which one suits you

How you use a watch Often a good fit
You want accuracy and little attention Quartz
You wear one watch every day Either. Automatic if you like the mechanics.
You rotate several watches Quartz, or an automatic with a winder
You enjoy the mechanical design Automatic
You want a low-cost everyday watch Quartz
You want a watch that is ready when you pick it up Quartz

Manual wind vs automatic watches covers the difference between the two mechanical types if you are looking at those.

Frequently asked questions

What’s better, an automatic or quartz watch?

Neither is better for everyone. Quartz is better for accuracy and low upkeep. An automatic is better for people who value mechanical design and do not mind winding, wearing and servicing the watch.

Which lasts longer, quartz or automatic?

Both can last for decades. An automatic depends on regular servicing. A quartz depends on battery changes and on whether the movement can still be repaired. A well-looked-after example of either can outlast its owner.

The complete guide to movements

Watch Movements Explained: Mechanical, Automatic and Quartz
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →