Why do collectors dislike quartz?
Mostly for reasons that have little to do with timekeeping. Quartz watches are more accurate than mechanical ones, and most collectors know it. The criticism comes from tradition, the value placed on hand craft, the history of the 1970s and 1980s, and a sense that a battery-powered watch is less of an heirloom. Some of these points are fair, and some are matters of taste.
What quartz does better
A quartz watch keeps time with a quartz crystal that vibrates at a steady frequency, and a small circuit counts those vibrations. The result is very consistent. A standard quartz watch is typically within about 15 seconds per month. By comparison, a COSC-certified mechanical chronometer must fall within about -4 to +6 seconds per day. For daily timekeeping, quartz is far more accurate. Radio-controlled and GPS watches are more accurate still, because they correct themselves against a time signal.
The Quartz Crisis and the “no quartz” slogan
The Seiko Astron, released in 1969, is widely cited as the first commercial quartz wristwatch. Through the 1970s and 1980s, affordable quartz watches from Japan spread quickly, and many Swiss makers struggled as a result. That period is often called the Quartz Crisis.
Some traditional brands answered with marketing that presented mechanical watches as the true standard. Blancpain’s well-known slogan, “There has never been a quartz Blancpain and there never will be,” is often quoted as an example. For many collectors, the slogan shaped how quartz was seen. It made quartz look like the less serious option, even though the technology was superior for accuracy.
Craft, heritage and the value of mechanical watches
Many collectors value a mechanical movement as a small machine built from gears, springs and a balance wheel. They see the hand finishing, the assembly and the long service life as part of the watch’s appeal. Critics of quartz say the movement lacks that character. A quartz movement is a battery, a circuit and a crystal, which can feel more like an appliance than a piece of craftsmanship.
Mechanical watches are also often marketed as heirlooms meant to be passed down. A battery-powered watch is seen by some as less likely to be kept for decades. That view is partly fair: quartz watches need battery changes, and a basic quartz watch is often easy to replace rather than service. It is also partly a matter of taste.
The ticking seconds hand
Most quartz watches move the second hand in a hard tick, one jump per second. A mechanical watch’s escapement usually gives a smoother sweep. Many people prefer the sweep, and the ticking motion is one of the most common complaints about quartz. Some quartz watches use a sweeping movement, however, so the feature depends on the model.
Quartz is not all the same
The criticism often targets basic quartz watches, which are mass-produced and cheap to make. High-end quartz is a different category. Grand Seiko’s 9F quartz movements are hand-finished and are respected by many collectors as a serious technical achievement. Experienced collectors often recognize that a good quartz movement can be an engineering feat, even if they still prefer mechanical watches.
Choosing between quartz and mechanical
The choice depends on what you want from a watch:
- Quartz offers high accuracy, low maintenance and, usually, a lower price for a given level of finishing.
- Mechanical offers craftsmanship, the visual appeal of a moving movement, and the tradition of the watch as a long-lived object that is serviced rather than replaced.
Neither choice is wrong. The criticism of quartz says more about the values of some collectors than about the watch’s ability to tell the time.
For the mechanical side of this comparison, see Tourbillon Watches: How They Work and How Accurate They Are, which explains why a mechanical complication does not improve accuracy on the wrist. For the wider family of complications, see the watch complications overview.