Light scratches on polished steel can sometimes be reduced with a soft polishing cloth and careful technique. Brushed finishes need work that follows the grain. Plated and coated cases can be damaged by polishing, and scratches on a mineral, Hardlex or sapphire crystal usually need replacing. When in doubt, stop and ask a professional.
Check the Finish First
Most steel watch cases have one of two finishes:
- Polished. A mirror-like surface that reflects light cleanly.
- Brushed or satin. A textured surface with fine parallel lines, common on sports watches.
Look at the case under a bright light and a magnifier. A polished finish looks even and reflective. A brushed finish shows fine lines. Some cases have both, such as polished bevels with brushed flat surfaces. Treat each area separately, and protect the other areas as you work.
Check the Case Material and Coating
The case material decides what is safe.
- Solid steel. Usually tolerant of careful polishing.
- Gold or platinum. These are softer metals, so the surface can change faster than you expect.
- Plated or coated cases. Gold plating and coatings such as PVD or DLC are thin layers. Polishing can wear through them, and that cannot be undone.
If you are not sure what the case is made of, do not polish it.
Polished Steel: Light Scratches
For a light scratch on a polished case:
- Clean the case thoroughly to remove grit, which can scratch as you rub.
- Protect nearby areas, such as brushed sections, with painter’s tape.
- Use a soft, pre-treated polishing cloth, or a very fine polishing compound made for watches.
- Rub the area lightly in small circular or straight strokes. Let the cloth do the work, and do not press hard.
- Wipe off the residue with a clean, dry microfiber cloth.
- Check the result under a magnifier, and repeat only if needed.
Stop as soon as the scratch fades. Over-polishing rounds the edges of the case and changes its shape.
Brushed Steel: Work With the Grain
Brushed finishes are made of many fine lines, so any new mark has to blend into them.
- Stroke only along the grain. Working across the grain creates cross-scratches that are harder to remove than the original mark.
- Use a fine abrasive pad. A fine, non-metallic pad, used with light pressure, can blend a scratch. Test on a small area first.
- Keep the pressure light. Coarse abrasives remove more metal than you intend.
- Clean thoroughly afterwards. Abrasive dust can lodge in the case and bracelet.
For a deep scratch on a brushed finish, an exact match is hard to achieve at home. A professional can often do better.
Scratches on the Crystal
Crystal scratches follow different rules:
- Acrylic. Some can be lightly buffed with a plastic polish. Test first.
- Mineral, Hardlex or sapphire. Hand polishing rarely removes scratches from these crystals. A deep scratch usually means the crystal needs replacing.
If you see a scratch on the crystal, identify the material before you try anything.
What to Avoid
- Toothpaste and baking soda. Both are abrasive and can leave fine scratches.
- Coarse sandpaper or scouring pads. These remove too much material.
- Rotary tools and felt wheels. They remove metal quickly, and they are for experienced professionals.
- Metal polishes not made for watches. They can be too aggressive for a watch case.
- Polishing plated, gold-plated or coated cases. The thin layer can wear through.
- Polishing vintage, hallmarked or valuable cases. Polishing can remove stamps and reduce value.
- Forcing polish near the bezel or edges. Pressure here can round off sharp lines.
Why Polishing Can Lower Value
A polished case has sharp, defined edges and a specific shape. Over-polishing softens those edges and can change the case’s outline. On a vintage or collectible watch, that can lower value, sometimes significantly. Hallmarks and engraving can also be lost. If the watch has any value to you, ask a professional first.
When to Stop and Call a Professional
Stop and get help if:
- the scratch is deep or leaves a visible groove
- the case has a dent, not only a scratch
- the watch is valuable, vintage or sentimental
- you are unsure of the finish or the material
- the scratch is on a brushed area and you cannot match the grain
Preventing New Scratches
Store the watch in a soft pouch or a lined box, away from other watches and hard objects. Keep it away from grit, and wipe it after wearing it. A soft cloth kept with the watch can help keep it clean.
For cleaning methods that do not abrade the case, see the guide to what to clean watches with. For an older or potentially valuable piece, the guide to telling if a pocket watch is worth money explains why you should check value before any work. If you are working on a Casio, the Casio restoration guide covers case and crystal care in that context.